The Dangers of Toxic Chemicals In Dog Toys And What You Can Do

Many pet parents assume that if a toy is sold online, it must be safe. But that couldn’t be further from the truth. A 2021 study by environmental researchers revealed that nearly 1 in 4 pet toys sold online contain harmful levels of toxic chemicals—including substances banned in children's toys. The worst part? Most of these dangers aren’t listed on the packaging.


What’s Actually In That Toy?

Cheap plastic and synthetic rubber toys are often laced with chemicals that serve a manufacturing purpose: to make the toy flexible, bright, or durable. But those same chemicals—like phthalates and bisphenol A (BPA)—have been linked to hormonal disruptions, organ damage, and developmental issues in animals.

According to the study, many of these toys would never meet U.S. safety standards for children’s products—but pets are not protected by the same regulations.


How These Chemicals Affect Your Pet

Even small amounts of these toxins can build up over time, especially for pets who chew, lick, and sleep next to their toys. Here’s what the research shows:

  • Phthalates (plastic softeners) can damage the liver and kidneys.

  • BPA (found in hard plastics) disrupts hormones and may affect mood or behavior.

  • Heavy metals like lead and chromium, found in paints or coatings, are linked to neurological and developmental harm.

Cats, who groom themselves frequently, are particularly vulnerable to chemical buildup, while dogs are at risk from heavy chewing and ingestion of tiny plastic fragments.


Are Pet Toys Even Regulated?

Unfortunately, no—not in the way most people assume. While children’s toys are subject to strict safety rules and toxicity thresholds, most pet toys are not federally regulated. Many of the products sold through large pet shop online platforms come from third-party manufacturers with little to no oversight.

This lack of regulation means it’s up to you—the pet owner—to be selective and informed when buying online pet products.


The Safer Solution: What You Can Do to Protect Your Pet

If you want to avoid harmful toxins and protect your pet’s health, the first step is to choose toys made from natural, non-toxic materials like natural rubber or organic fabrics. But there’s more you can do to reduce exposure and create a safer environment for your furry companion:

1. Wash Toys Regularly

Toys collect saliva, dirt, and household dust—which can all contain traces of chemicals or allergens. Clean rubber toys weekly with warm water and mild soap, and machine wash soft toys when possible.

2. Avoid Fragranced or “Scented” Products

If a toy has a strong artificial smell, it likely contains chemical additives. These synthetic fragrances can irritate pets’ sensitive noses or cause allergic reactions over time.

3. Check for Wear and Tear

Fraying seams, cracked rubber, or missing pieces are signs a toy is no longer safe. Small broken bits can become choking hazards or introduce unwanted materials into your pet’s system.

4. Limit Exposure to Cheap Plastic Items

Plastic bowls, synthetic beds, or cheap collars may also leach toxins. Choosing safer pet accessories across the board—like food-grade silicone bowls or organic fabric beds—helps reduce your pet’s chemical load overall.


How to Shop Smarter for Pet Accessories

When you’re browsing pet supplies online, especially on large marketplaces, watch out for:

  • Vague descriptions or missing material information

  • Strong chemical smells or unnatural colors

  • Toys labeled “rubber” but priced suspiciously low (likely synthetic blends)

  • Sellers who don't provide transparency about ingredients or sourcing

Instead, look for brands that are focused on creating safe, sustainable fun—because your pet deserves better than a bargain bin hazard.


Play It Safe—Your Pet Will Thank You

Toys are meant to bring joy—not hidden harm. The reality is that too many common pet toys expose animals to dangerous chemicals simply because no one’s watching. But you can be the difference. By choosing safe, natural toys from trusted sources like Atlantic Animals, you’re giving your pet healthier playtime and protecting them from long-term health issues.

Make the switch to non-toxic, natural rubber toys today and see the difference in your pet’s happiness and energy.


Shop Atlantic Animals for safe, online pet products that deliver real peace of mind.

Back to blog

Leave a comment